Hello everyone !
My friend @Sensei told me that the weapons A grade were giving more p.atack than B. Then I show him how BOP+5 and Carnage +2, two weapons with same p.attack, give the same amount of P.atack to the char.
After, he demonstrate me how a Carnage +10 was giving more p.atack to the character than a BOP +14 which must be false because the p.atack of the weapon BOP +14 is greater. Then I made my own experiment:
So I tried many bows and I did the following table:
Bow of Peril
Carnage Bow
Ench
Weap P.atack
Char P.Atack
Increase for+1
Ench
Weap. P.Atack
P.Atack
Increase for+1
5
456
2089
0
440
2026
6
472
2153
64
1
448
2058
32
7
488
2216
63
2
456
2089
31
8
504
2279
63
3
464
2121
32
9
520
2343
64
4
480
2216
95
10
536
2406
63
5
496
2311
95
11
552
2470
64
6
512
2406
95
12
568
2533
63
7
528
2501
95
13
584
2596
63
8
544
2596
95
14
600
2660
64
9
560
2691
95
15
616
2723
63
10
576
2786
95
16
632
2786
63
11
592
2881
95
17
648
2850
64
12
608
2976
95
18
664
2913
63
13
624
3071
95
19
680
2976
63
14
640
3167
96
20
696
3040
64
15
656
3262
95
- The p.atack of all the weapons grow on the same rate. (+8 p.atack on safe enchant and +16 p.atack on overenchant).
- The bonus on the BOP is as intended, giving char p.atack on the enchants on +4 and above.
- The Carnage bow, when it is enchanted by +4 or more, is increasing the char P.atack by more than intended. Every enchant is giving 95 p.atack to the char when it is supposed to give 63 like the BOP. Every enchant gives the same amount of p.atack to the weapon and so to the char.
- So a Carnage +10 now is giving same stats than a BOP +16 when it should give less p.atack than a BOP+13.
- That means that for every +2 OE on your Carnage bow is like you make a +3 on your BOP.
Conclusions
A-grade over-enchanted weapons are giving more stats to the characters than intended.