problem is, mages/tyrant doing ridiculous damage and no blessed soulshots
if you have mages hitting for 1-2k normals and 4k+ crits, then ofc archer critting for 1.5-2k to actual normal people seems low, if mages were nuking like they should (600-800 normal, max 2k crit if you are non-hero), then crit from archer for 1.5k wouldnt seem that bad tbh, because you dont waste MP on it and fights would last much longer
tho like rizos said, also its problem that for some reason, there is 12938012389423 tanks which are tankier than on official (yes, i am looking on you, DAs with +12 WIT setup while being immortal), here the physical crit dmg to bards/tanks if absolute joke in addition to block rate
imagine normal mage hitting like this, then i would take 1.6k crits on archer (coz with othell, you crit quite often) but if you make 1.5k normal on mage like here, then ofc, hitting every single time same like archer crit and doing triple the damage when you crit is better, fights end much faster coz mages melt everything and thus there is no worry about running out of mana