The thing is, the classic oldschool fishing is something that some people absolutely love and associate with Lineage 2 in it's early years. After all, the whole Classic is about nostalgia. Those who don't use it, simply don't care about it since it's just another feature they don't use.
On the other hand you have this new revamped automatic fishing, which I dare to say most people consider just a 'necessary evil'. It's basically nothing but a legal bot. I mean out of all people, I thought it would be you who would be loudest against it - everytime someone suggest something to ease up the game or help the newbies, either you or modoy are the first to say it doesn't belong to the game. Does botting belong to the game? If not, how does this system differentiate from botting? Now everyone will be able to exp/earn adena without playing.